“What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” by The Decemberists

January 20. 2015 | By Jason Martinez


The Decemberists
What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World

The Decemberists return after a four year absence, and we’re glad to have indie rock’s most poetic band back, even if the Portland band’s seventh effort falls a bit short of their best. Much of the album sounds like they’ve been listening to ‘70s rock radio, all wide open guitars and groovy basslines. The songs are good, but except for the plaintive “Philomena,” none have the immediate charm of, say, America’s “Sister Golden Hair.”

The most effective numbers are the ones where they dwell on the first half of the album’s titular equation. In the meta-as-hell “The Singer Addresses His Audience,” vocalist Colin Meloy laments a wedding backed by a song made for “the benefit of Axe Shampoo.” The somber “Carolina Low” finds Meloy’s pen as poisonous as ever, and stands with their best material.

In the end, they do navigate to the beautiful part of the world though, especially with the gorgeous closer “A Beginning Song.” “Bright light, it’s all around me,” sighs Meloy, and like the bruised Rust Cohle at the end of True Detective, you believe him. Even an average Decemberists album gives you a lot to admire, it just feels that they’ve given us more before.

  • The Owl Mag | The Best Indie Music News, Album Reviews, and Free MP3s